Two beam geometries are used for this gravitational load validation. They have a cross-section of 0.05 x 0.05 \(m^2\) and 1 \(m\) length (l). The first one consists of unrotated beam geometry, shown below:

The second geometry is rotated 45º around the positive x-axis:

The coordinates for the points in the first geometry are as tabulated below:

Mesh and Element Types: The meshes for cases A and B were created in SimScale. The standard algorithm was used. The meshes from case A and B were downloaded, rotated by 45º around the positive x-axis, and imported to SimScale. They were used for cases C and D, respectively. With this method, we achieve the same meshes for the rotated and unrotated cases.

Case

Geometry

Mesh Type

Number of Nodes

Element Type

(A)

Beam – original

Standard – tetrahedral cells

12737

1st order

(B)

Beam – original

Standard – tetrahedral cells

91499

1st order

(C)

Beam – rotated

Standard – tetrahedral cells

12737

2nd order

(D)

Beam – rotated

Standard – tetrahedral cells

91499

2nd order

Table 3: Mesh characteristics.

Find below the mesh used for case D. It’s a standard mesh with second-order tetrahedral cells.

Simulation Setup

Material:

Steel (linear elastic)

\(E\) = 205 \(GPa\)

\(\nu\) = 0.28

\(\rho\) = 7870 \(kg/m³\)

Boundary Conditions:

Constraints

Fixed support on face ABCD.

Gravity (defined under model):

Cases A and B: 9.81 \(m/s²\) in the negative z-direction (0, 0, -1);

Cases C and D: 9.81 \(m/s²\) rotated 45º around the positive x-direction (0, 1, -1)

Reference Solution

Converting the gravitational load to a line load \((w_a)\):

The equation (4) below is derived from [Roark]\(^1\)

$$y(l) = -\frac{w_a l^4}{8 E I} = -2.2597 \cdot 10^{-4}\ m \tag {4}$$

Result Comparison

The table below shows the SimScale results for the displacement at the free end (face A’B’C’D’) in the gravity direction. Results are compared to the analytical solution by [Roark].

Case

Quantity

[Roark]

SimScale

Error (%)

(A)

Displacement at the free end \([m]\)

-2.2597e-4

-2.1480e-4

-5.20

(B)

Displacement at the free end \([m]\)

-2.2597e-4

-2.2560e-4

-0.16

(C)

Displacement at the free end \([m]\)

-2.2597e-4

-2.1480e-4

-5.20

(D)

Displacement at the free end \([m]\)

-2.2597e-4

-2.2560e-4

-0.16

Table 4: Comparison of SimScale’s results against an analytical solution.

Inspecting the displacements in the z-direction for case B:

References

W. C. YOUNG, R. G. BUDYNAS. Roark’s Formulas for Stress and Strain. Seventh Edition. McGraw-Hill. 2002. p. 191.

Last updated: June 30th, 2020

Did you find this article helpful?

How can we do better?

We appreciate and value your feedback.

Contents

Cookie Policy

SimScale uses cookies to improve your user experience. By using this website you consent to our cookie policy.

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.

Strictly Necessary Cookies

Strictly Necessary Cookie should be enabled at all times so that we can save your preferences for cookie settings.

If you disable this cookie, we will not be able to save your preferences. This means that every time you visit this website you will need to enable or disable cookies again.