Passive Cooling vs. Active Cooling – What’s the Difference?
March 13th, 2018
approx reading time
BlogCAE HubPassive Cooling vs. Active Cooling – What’s the Difference?
A common problem in product design—particularly in electronics—is managing thermal conditions for optimal efficiency. The core of the challenge is designing energy-efficient microprocessors and printed circuit boards (PCBs) that will not overheat.
A frequently overlooked aspect of thermal management problem solving is architectural design. Whether it’s a private home, an office building, or a dedicated server room, architectural considerations can have a huge impact on the thermal management solutions available.
To tackle and alleviate the difficulties and inefficiencies that arise as a result of heat, engineers employ different cooling systems to manage conditions. These systems can be divided into two main categories: those with active and with passive cooling techniques. But what is the difference between them?
The advantages of passive cooling techniques lie in the energy efficiency and lower financial cost, making it an astute systems design choice for the thermal management of both buildings and electronic products.
Passive cooling achieves high levels of natural convection and heat dissipation by utilizing a heat spreader or a heat sink to maximize the radiation and convection heat transfer modes. In architectural design, natural resources like wind or soil are used as heat sinks to absorb or dissipate heat. This leads to proper cooling of electronic products and thermal comfort in homes or office buildings by keeping them under the maximum allowed operating temperature. A growing trend in this regards can be witnessed in what is commonly known in the industry as passive houses.
To sum it up—passive thermal management is a cost-effective and energy-efficient solution that relies on heat sinks, heat spreaders, heat pipes or thermal interface materials (TIM) to maintain optimal operating temperatures.
Active cooling, on the other hand, refers to cooling technologies that rely on an external device to enhance heat transfer. Through active cooling technologies, the rate of fluid flow increases during convection, which dramatically increases the rate of heat removal.
Active cooling solutions include forced air through a fan or blower, forced liquid, and thermoelectric coolers (TECs), which can be used to optimize thermal management on all levels. Fans are used when natural convection is insufficient to remove heat. They are commonly integrated into electronics, such as computer cases, or are attached to CPUs, hard drives or chipsets to maintain thermal conditions and reduce failure risk.
The main disadvantage of active thermal management is that it requires the use of electricity and therefore results in higher costs, compared to passive cooling.
By performing early-stage thermal simulations, designers can predict the airflow, temperature distribution, and heat transfer in systems. These analyses reduce the number of unnecessary physical prototypes, resulting in design process efficiency and significantly reduced costs. In this public project, aheat sink design was analyzed through conjugate heat transfer simulation, with the purpose of optimizing it to ensure proper cooling.
Thermal analysis software can also help you make an informed decision when considering active and passive cooling techniques. This workshop recording and its step-by-step tutorial will help you compare active and passive cooling of a Raspberry Pi house by performing a simulation. Use the SimScale platform for free to follow this tutorial. Create an account or start a free 14-day trial.
Despite the significant manufacturing cost reduction of electronic boards and prototype enclosures for devices, it is still a daunting and time-consuming task to analyze the thermal performance of a new design. Download this free case study to learn how the thermal performance of a printed circuit board was investigated with SimScale using thermal analysis.