Carbomech used SimScale FEA to develop a high-speed motorized spindle

50% less prototypes physically tested by adding SimScale in the design phase

Less physical prototypes

From CAD to results in less than 1 hour

Time from CAD to results

Carbomech logo

Carbomech is an innovative start-up company established in Italy in 2015 with the goal to develop high-end and unique spindles running up to 250,000 revolutions per minute. The spindles are equipped with powerful DC motors and used for drilling operations specially for the printed circuit industry. Based in the area of Turin, Carbomech has a hand-selected group of experienced engineers who work to provide innovative solutions to the PCB and CNC machining industries.

The Challenge

Find Natural Frequencies of a High-Speed Spindle Shaft and Dimension It with Strength Analysis

Carbomech wanted to bring to the market a new air bearing spindle equipped with a DC motor which would be able to reach 180,000 rpm during operation. Finite element analysis (FEA) was used throughout the design phase to find the natural frequencies and modes of this design proposal and at the same time to dimension its geometry to guarantee that, when achieving high speeds, the deformation of the shaft’s shape wouldn’t generate issues with the air bearings.

spindle developed by Carbomech and optimized with SimScale
CM180 spindle developed by Carbomech and optimized with SimScale

Being a startup, Carbomech could not afford to test all the design proposals they had. Consequently, adding numerical simulations early in the design phase of this new spindle was the right solution to save time and money while knowing that the results were accurate.

A big part of the experience with SimScale is the support. Even if SimScale gets better and better, there are so many choices. You must have somebody helping you to choose!

Fabrizio Pauri

Fabrizio Pauri

CEO and Chief Engineer, Carbomech

How they solved it with SimScale

Finding Natural Frequencies and Elastic Deformation Due to the Shaft’s Rotational Speed

The project involved running a modal analysis to find the right compromise between stiffness and mass. The aim was to operate the shaft at speeds safely distant from the natural frequencies where spindle destruction is certain.

First natural mode: bending, FEA of a spindle by Carbomech with SimScale
First natural mode: bending

After achieving a desired configuration based on the natural modes and frequencies, Carbomech’s CEO and Chief Engineer Fabrizio Pauri also ran a centrifugal load analysis of the shaft to check stresses and deformation on the spindle at 180,000 rpm.

The spindles measure around 0.13m in length and have different cross sections with the outer diameter varying from 6mm to 20mm. In order to properly assess this kind of geometries, a second order element mesh was created with around 500 thousand elements.

second order element mesh used for modal and strength analysis of a spindle by Carbomech with SimScale
Second order element mesh used for modal and strength analysis

A modal analysis was then performed for two different spindle designs as part of the first stage in the development phase. The main goal was to assess the natural frequencies and modes of the spindles in order to check if changes in terms of mass distribution would be needed to guarantee a good stiffness.

Finding the natural frequencies helped to define the speed range where the shaft can run safely.

Second natural mode: radial expansion, FEA of a spindle by Carbomech with SimScale
Second natural mode: radial expansion

Operating the spindle too near to a natural frequency would deform the shaft in such a way that it will crash against the surfaces of the air bearings.

Third natural mode: rotation, radial expansion, FEA of a spindle by Carbomech with SimScale
Third natural mode: rotation

Following the design phase, a centrifugal load analysis was then performed by using the same second order element mesh which was previously created. Boundary conditions were then assigned to mimic the air bearing case and a centrifugal load of 180,000 rpm was applied to the spindle.

With this kind of analysis, the main goal was to assess the displacement around the ‘disk’ which stays inside the bearing’s case and has limited space to expand due to a high rotational speed. The stresses were also assessed with the online post-processor tool available inside SimScale.

stress distribution for original and deformed shape of a spindle, FEA in the web browser with SimScale
Stress distribution for the original and deformed shape

The results

Calculating Displacement and Reducing Physical Prototypes by 50%

Since the gap between parts in relative movement is in the range of few micrometers where air bearings are used, it is crucial to correctly simulate all the deformations of the shaft.

Displacement distribution for the original and deformed shape, FEA of a spindle by Carbomech with SimScale
Displacement distribution for the original and deformed shape

With the use of FEA with the SimScale cloud-based platform, the Carbomech team could then calculate the displacement due to the high speed of the spindle on this region of interest, at 180,000 rotations per minute.

“Support is super good! The few times I had something wrong or hadn’t understood something, I would simply email the Customer Success Engineer and minutes later the solution was there. I can only say that the level of support is very good!”

The FEA simulations performed in the cloud with SimScale gave Carbomech’s team valuable insights into the mechanical performance of their high-speed spindle.

The team had to build 50% less prototypes for physical testing than usual by adding SimScale to the design phase. The price of each spindle is 3-4 times more than a SimScale subscription, which makes the return on investment (ROI) very high.

Next Steps

Continuing to Use SimScale to Finalize the Current Project and Future Ones

Carbomech team: Fabrizio Pauri, Fabrizio Pejla, Alex Vallino (from the left)
Carbomech team: Fabrizio Pauri, Fabrizio Pejla, Alex Vallino (from the left)

The current CM180 spindle has been redesigned by using the results from simulations made with SimScale. An improved design has already been validated by further simulations with the platform and is currently in development.

“Well, I have a dedicated Customer Success Engineer watching over me, helping me to actually squeeze out the value from the service. What more can I ask for?”

See More Success Stories

Customer Case Study

Aqseptence Group

Customer Case Study

Furnace Fixers

Customer Case Study

Anderson CNC

Customer Case Study

Meccanica

Find out how engineering simulation can help engineers optimize industries equipment and machinery!