websights

Fill out the form to download

Required field
Required field
Not a valid email address
Required field
Required field
airlit studio logo

AIRLIT studio Studies Natural
Ventilation in Library Building

Challenge

  • Evaluate the natural ventilation performance of a library building.
  • Simulate external and internal air flows simultaneously.
  • Identify areas of high wind drafts internally.
  • Suggest options for energy saving and increased occupant comfort.

Results

  • Ran external wind simulations based on annual weather data and used the results to feed into the internal airflow analysis.
  • Simulated buoyancy and wind-driven flow throughout the building.
  • Identified high-wind-speed areas internally that risk compromising occupant comfort.
  • Optioneering for strategies to extend the usability of natural ventilation and reduce energy costs.
3D Rhino CAD model of the University Library
simulation of library temperature profiles

AIRLIT studio

AIRLIT studio is an environmental design consultancy with an approach rooted in technical excellence and focused on developing sustainable and innovative solutions for buildings and entire developments. Its approach is centered around occupants and how they will experience a building and its environment. AIRLIT studio offers a suite of simulation services that drive analytical approaches to answering building performance questions.

A Holistic Approach to Environmental Design

As part of the design process, the studio assists its clients in framing the intent behind an energy, comfort, or indoor air quality analysis, considering factors such as the design concept, project schedule, cost, or other key drivers. The use of simulation tools is used to design for the following variables and performance indicators:

  • Human well-being
  • Visual and thermal comfort
  • Overall indoor environmental quality
  • Operational and embodied carbon emissions
  • HVAC system sizing
  • Budget and maintenance considerations
  • Aesthetic appeal

AIRLIT studio has recently introduced SimScale as part of its core simulation and analysis offering, led by Alonso, a Founding Principal at AIRLIT studio. Alonso is an expert in solving first principles in building science to achieve high-performance and occupant-centric solutions in the built environment. He leverages this experience in mechanical system design, energy and comfort analysis, and computational fluid dynamics (CFD) to find cost-effective and low-carbon solutions that meet clients’ aspirations. Alonso’s diverse project experience includes university campuses, science labs, museums, performing arts centers, elementary schools, and residential and office buildings. In addition, he has collaborated with states and cities to develop cutting-edge carbon neutrality policies. Notably, he contributed to the design of New York and Boston’s first all-electric skyscrapers and is now driving the adoption and usage of SimScale CFD and microclimate tools.

Using SimScale is a treat for those of us who love to combine architecture and engineering. We have used at least three other CFD packages in our professional lives, and nothing is as easy to use or as powerful as SimScale. We love how easy it is to use the interface, and yet how powerful the platform and tech support are to model complex physical phenomena including complex airflows around buildings and cities and indoor air quality using natural ventilation.

Alonso Dominguez, PhD

Principal at AIRLIT studio

A New Library at The University of Lima

AIRLIT studio used SimScale to support the design of a 9-story naturally ventilated library building at the University of Lima (Peru), designed by Sasaki Architects. As part of the wider energy and comfort design, Alonso used SimScale to answer questions that can’t be addressed using simpler bulk airflow models, like: 

  • “How will the air stratify in a large volume?”
  • “How will the wind impact wind pressure coefficients along the façade?”, or 
  • “What specific areas within the building may experience uncomfortable drafts?”

These problems are investigated by typically running large-scale simulations of incompressible flow, where the team is looking to understand air speeds. flow rates. and temperature distribution in indoor spaces. The workflow begins with a Rhino model provided by the architect, which was imported into SimScale after some CAD cleanup and modifications.

3D Rhino CAD model of the University Library (center building)
3D Rhino CAD model of the University Library (center building)
Rendering of the University Library (center building)
Rendering of the University Library (center building), image courtesy of Sasaki

Design Questions

AIRLIT studio was tasked by the architect to understand how the current natural ventilation design performs in terms of thermal comfort and air velocities under buoyancy (only) and wind-driven conditions. This was necessary to form an understanding of how the library ventilation in floors 3 to 8, thermal comfort indoor air quality is impacted by natural ventilation at present. To do this, Alonso set up interior and exterior CFD simulations using SimScale with two scenarios:

  1. Buoyancy only to assess indoor air temperature.
  2. Wind only to assess potential drafts under wind conditions.

A good starting point is a climate analysis. Alonso’s team evaluated the annual and seasonal data for wind speeds and directions in Lima, Peru, to ascertain the correct external wind conditions needed for the simulation setup. This data can be edited to suit the local terrain and site and then imported into SimScale for incompressible external airflow simulation using OpenFOAM.

seasonal wind analysis of wind speed and directions in Lima
A seasonal wind analysis of wind speed and directions in Lima, Peru.

Buoyancy Only

In this buoyancy-only scenario, the purpose of the study was to simulate temperature-driven air flow through the library building. Differences in air temperature between the exterior and interior air cause density variations that drive airflow. These temperature differences can come from heat gains from external sources (solar gains, conduction through the walls, or convective heat transfer through infiltration, window openings, etc.) or internal heat gains (heat emitted by occupants, lights, equipment, for example). In this case, the team wanted to understand the impact of heat gains on indoor temperature distribution. Thermal comfort boundaries were set at 18℃ – 26℃ as per the local guidelines, and thermal mass effects were not accounted for as a conservative scenario. The study focused on floors 3-7.

simulation of library temperature profiles
ΔT (Outside minus inside) temperature profiles in ℃ inside the library. Higher temperature differences are seen as the air rises toward the top, where openings are placed strategically to facilitate natural ventilation. This scenario is for buoyancy-driven air flow only (no wind).
temperature profile simulation of floor 3 temperature profile simulation of floor 4 temperature profile simulation of floor 4 temperature profile simulation of floor 6 temperature profile simulation of floor 7
ΔT Temperature profiles in ℃
ΔT Temperature profiles in ℃ inside the library by floor. Higher temperatures are seen as the air rises towards the top (floor 7), where openings are placed strategically to facilitate natural ventilation. This scenario is for buoyancy-driven air flow only (no wind).

The current design is considered appropriate from a thermal standpoint. Thermal stratification is observed throughout the building: Lower floors are expected to be 3-4℃ cooler than upper floors. The floor temperatures are overall uniform in each floor, and while warmer, the upper floors remain within 5-6°C of outdoor air temperature which is considered acceptable.

It is expected that natural ventilation will be feasible between 52% and 62% of occupied hours (upper and lower floors, respectively), and keeping the window open at night will increase the passive cooling hours by almost 20%-30%. From the climate analysis and annual simulations, it can be seen that January – March may be too hot/humid to use natural ventilation.

Wind-Driven Airflows & Natural Ventilation

In the wind-driven scenario, the purpose of the study was to evaluate the impact of wind on potential interior draft conditions. In the first simulation run, the setup was as follows:

  • Far-field wind speed: 2 m/s at 10 m from ground 
  • Wind direction: South
  • No internal gains assumed
  • Maximum windy draft threshold: 1m/s (when papers fly off desks)

Indoor air speeds in most areas are expected to remain under 0.5 m/s, which is considered appropriate when evaluating wind drafts in naturally ventilated buildings. The 1m/s threshold may be exceeded when meteorological speeds exceed 4m/s, which is 15% of the time, annually.

Summary

The current design of the new library of the University of Lima will achieve comfortable conditions most of the year:

  • Upper floors are expected to be roughly 3-4°C warmer than lower floors. This is acceptable, so long as the upper floor doesn’t exceed the maximum temperature threshold for comfort.
  • The temperature along each floor is expected to be fairly uniform, which is desirable.
  • Under typical wind conditions, most of the floorplates are draft-free. 
  • Based on these results, it is expected that natural ventilation will be able to be used at least 52% of occupied annual hours, with the potential of 80% usage if night cooling is implemented as a strategy, particularly along the upper floors.
  • AIRLIT studio is now tailoring specific recommendations to increase the range of natural ventilation use throughout the year. 

These findings could only have been made possible with the use of CFD tools such as SimScale.

Set up your own cloud-native simulation via the web in minutes by creating an account on the SimScale platform. No installation, special hardware, or credit card is required.