I would like to reset the simulation Mesh settings to where they were when mesh was created, which would remove this warning:
Is there a way to do so?
I tried copying the mesh settings from Mesh 1 but that was a disaster because I can not get back to where it was and it wanted me to generate a new mesh 
Thanks,
Dale
Hi Dale,
as for now there is no way to remember the old settings. If you are uncertain about future optimizations I would just create a copy of the mesh and work with that.
Cheers,
Jousef
If I do that, what is the purpose of being able to select different meshes for simulation runs?
Right now, just because I tried the âcopy mesh settingsâ from the same mesh, my whole simulation parameters were lost 
and a lot of red in a simulation that has many good runs
Hi Dale!
Maybe @sguenther can provide you with more information on this issue and if there is anything planned.
Cheers,
Jousef
Hi @DaleKramer,
Those are actually two different topics that came up here. Let me explain:
But @jousefm is right. The best way to preserve old mesh settings is to copy your mesh after it has been generated and to make any modifications only on the copy. This way you have a history of meshes to choose from.
But there is a very elegant way to work around that limitation. Check out our Fluid Volume Extraction feature, which letâs you define the fluid domain on the CAD-level already. This way, all your meshes will (most likely) be able to be mapped to your CAD model, making a simple switch of meshes without losing the assignments possible.
Let me know in case you need help or have more questions.
Best,
Sebastian
Hi Sebastian ,
I have found many more issues trying to work with meshes which are sortof embedded into simulation trees and I definitely want to explore Fluid Volume Extraction.
For instance, if I start a new simulation 2 and copy mesh settings from another meshed used in simulation 1 and then change the name of the new mesh in simulation 2 , the mesh name in the old simulation 1 is also changed and all changes I make to the new mesh in simulation 2 parameters automatically change in the simulation 1 tree too. I can not think that this is what is intendedâŚ
I have tried Fluid Volume Extraction in this project which uses a pretty typical geometry which I can not seem to extract an open inner region from, here is what it looks like. I do not know what face to select as a seed since the inlet and outlet faces do not have a border face around them. :
Before I go back and modify the CAD file to create those borders, is there a way to do it on the existing CAD file?
Why canât the fluid volume be extracted by using the already existing Geometry Primitive âMaterial Pointâ, instead of a seed face?
Also, I am very concerned that this CAD file has an MRF as a rotating zone in it (see geometry named MRF) and that MRF will confuse your code that generates the fluid volume⌠I think you need an âExclusionâ selection frame too 
Thanks,
Dale
Hi @DaleKramer,
regarding the confusion around meshing:
Meshes are not specific to one simulation, but shared across all of them. That means that making changes in one simulation, will change the mesh everywhere else it is assigned as well. This is intended, but weâre working on a few ideas to make that more obvious in the workbench interface.
In regards to the fluid volume extraction problems:
The case you show above canât be used for flow volume extraction unfortunately, since you already have an extracted fluid volume. In your case youâd need to perform a boolean operation to cut the rotor out of the fluid domain.
For the flow volume extraction to work for your case, youâd need the walls of the duct as well as the rotor, but still couldnât keep the MRF zone. Bottom line: Flow volume extraction is not yet optimized for use with rotating zones. But the airship case above would be an ideal use case for it.
Best,
Sebastian
Thanks,
I will try to better explain my issue with meshing in another reply after I figure out how to explain it better ( In post #6, I poorly explained my issue) 
Is it possible to do the subtraction of the rotor from the walls in CAD and then use that as an âopen inner regionâ for further assignments in SimScale?
Hi Dale!
Would be interesting to know how you solved this issue. Others might benefit from that 
Best,
Jousef
Actually, I decided I have too many different project types on the go and I was beginning to ask questions about things that were not related to this main topic issue.
In the meantime Bryce has created a topic on Fluid Volume Extractions and I want to see where that goes.
I think I will leave this topic relatively untouched and summarize that the ability to Reset meshing to where they were when a mesh was created does NOT exist.
Which is too bad because this is sorely neededâŚ
A small step towards that end, Sebastian stated:
AND, I just tried to see if this single issue about renaming a mesh was fixed yet, but it is not 
So, watch for new topics after I do some more testing 
Sorry of confusion, mainly mine. 
