Hello everyone,
I am working on a project “Cantilever Snap Fit Design” from “The “Solve it with SimScale” Project”. My results don’t match with the experimental data presented in the paper. For details see the project’s comment.
I would appreciate any suggestions you have!.
Hi @atanas_kuzev,
The project looks awesome! Here are a few suggestions-
-
Use finer mesh on the snap. This shall definitely cause the simulation to run for a longer period of time, but the results should be much closer to the experimentally validated results.
-
The penetration between the snap and the fixed block is too high. This can be avoided in two ways- either use Augmented Lagrangian contacts (which are not as stable as penalty, but do not allow any penetration) or increase the penalty coefficient (by 10-100x)
-
The displacement is not sufficient, and hence the final “snap” is not occurring. Please provide a higher displacement to the body (in the positive x-direction)
-
I am not sure about the fillet radius. Please check on that once again, as the fillet radius (especially at the neck of the snap) can cause a big variation in the results.
Hope this helps!
Regards,
Vikrant Srivastava
Hi @vsriv90,
Thanks for your reply.
I tried to use Augmented Lagrangian contacts, but I got this message:
What’s wrong with my settings?
Hey @atanas_kuzev,
I once again had a look at your simulation: as you are using a symmetry, the nodes common between the “symmetry” boundary condition and the “Augmented Lagrangian” contacts have two very separate conditions acting on them. Hence, they cause a singularity and result in this error.
What you can do with Augmented Lagrangian is use a complete body. But in case of this simulation, I would suggest using a Penalty contact formulation - they are much more stable, and a high value of the penalty coefficient shall ensure that there is no penetration.
Regards,
Vikrant Srivastava
Hi @vsriv90,
- I used higher values for penalty coefficients, but the simulations took a long time to run (from my point of view - many core hours used without results) and I canceled them.
- How can I set up mesh refinement using an edge/ a point?